Watchdog urges removal of religion from Australian terrorism definition
Religion Desk
Australia's national security laws watchdog has recommended that religion be excluded from the nation's legal definition of terrorism. The Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM) released its long-awaited report on Thursday, which assessed how terrorism has been defined in the country over the last 25 years following the introduction of laws after the September 11 attacks in the United States.
Advertisement
The report also suggested that individuals who make bomb threats should no longer face potential life imprisonment. This development follows warnings from the Australian Federal Police (AFP) and the Australian Security and Intelligence Organisation (Asio) that the rise of violent nationalism has shifted the threat landscape, making it difficult to categorise the motivations behind certain terrorist attacks into single ideologies.
Jake Blight, the head of the INSLM, argued that the current legal requirement to prove a terrorist was advancing a religious cause grants them “false credibility” and negatively affects religious minorities. The report stated, “Having a law that requires proof that terrorists were advancing a ‘religious’ cause gives these terrorists false credibility and reinforces their narrative that they are doing holy work.” It added that these individuals could still be prosecuted but should instead be labelled as violent ideologues.
Furthermore, the document noted that including religion in the definition has historically contributed to discrimination and violence against religious minorities, particularly Muslim Australians, which harms social cohesion. Currently, the federal criminal code mandates that authorities prove an act intended to cause serious harm to people or property to advance a political, religious or ideological cause.
Mr Blight’s report suggested that moving religion from a primary motivation to an example of a broader “ideology” category would align Australia with international best practice. The INSLM highlighted that a report from the UN special rapporteur earlier this year recommended defining terrorist acts by political and ideological causes while omitting religious motives to avoid “discriminatory and stigmatizing effects that outweigh the benefits of criminally denouncing them”.
Advertisement
Aftab Malik, Australia’s special envoy to combat Islamophobia, stated in his submission to the INSLM that retaining religion as a terrorist motivation creates a “climate of suspicion” regarding Muslims and offers “ammunition for far-right extremist narratives”. Eleven Muslim advocacy groups, such as the Australian Muslim Advocacy Network, supported the report’s findings and called on the government to change the laws.
In a joint statement, these groups said, “Every time someone in authority says that a motivation is ‘religious’, it uplifts ISIS, far-right and harmful media narratives all at once, by officially perpetuating the false premise that Islam encourages terrorism.” They added that this situation makes all Muslims feel as though they are “under siege.”
However, the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, which is the nation’s peak Jewish body, described the report as “high-quality” but questioned the proposal. Peter Wertheim, the organisation’s co-chief executive, said it made “little sense when so many notorious terrorist acts have featured motifs, words and images that unmistakably refer to religious doctrines and beliefs”.
Mr Wertheim further noted, “The inclusion of ‘faith’ as a type of ideology does not solve the problem. Faith is not the same as religion and religion is more than an ideology.” He argued that it is inappropriate for Australian law to determine which religious expressions are authentic, as adherents of a single faith may hold differing views.
Advertisement
The INSLM report included six additional recommendations, including the separation of credible terrorist threats from actual acts of terrorism. Current laws allow for a life sentence for those found guilty of making a credible terrorist threat, with a mandatory minimum of six years. The report deemed this punishment “disproportionate, unnecessarily complex and out of step with international standards” and proposed that such threats should carry a maximum sentence of no more than five years.
Additionally, the monitor recommended increasing the threshold for designating damage to property or electronic systems as acts of terrorism, while explicitly excluding protest, advocacy, dissent, and industrial action. Asio director-general Mike Burgess has previously warned about the growth of violent nationalist extremism. In an October submission to a parliamentary inquiry, Asio reported that approximately 65% of its counter-terrorism caseload involved religiously-motivated violent extremism, while 35% was attributed to ideologically-motivated extremism.