Could the rise of a US Christian left influence Australian politics
Religion Desk
There was a period, living in recent memory, when the Australian church possessed a clear and active left wing. This included Palm Sunday peace marches, guitar masses, and priests returning from distant missions with tales of liberation theology. During the early 2000s, there was also powerful, sustained activism opposing government policies regarding mandatory detention.
Advertisement
For the church's left wing, Jesus was seen as an anti-capitalist who overturned the tables of money lenders. He instructed a wealthy young man to sell his belongings, distribute the proceeds to the poor, and follow him, noting it was easier for a camel to pass through a needle's eye than for a rich man to enter heaven. However, this style of Christianity faded by the mid-2000s, and for over 20 years, the most prominent Christian voices in politics were from the right.
These decades in Australia saw the rise of individualism under Howard as his battlers filled megachurches. There was also Tony Abbott, an ex-seminarian prime minister who refused his party a conscience vote on same-sex marriage, and Scott Morrison, who was seen with his hands raised at the Horizon church. Morrison practiced the evangelical tradition of the “laying-on of hands” when visiting unsuspecting victims of trauma in evacuation centres.
While the two most recent popes, Francis and Leo, have been progressive, the Christian right has dominated the political space so thoroughly that it is hard to imagine what a Christian left might look or sound like, or how they would govern. This month in the US, James Talarico, a progressive Presbyterian seminarian, won Texas for the Democrats, providing a sense of how a new Christian left could animate politics.
Talarico spoke of loving thy neighbour as thyself and welcoming the stranger in response to the Republican stance on immigration. He repeatedly cited Matthew 25 as scriptural authority for caring for the vulnerable, feeding the hungry, clothing the poor and caring for the sick. He further argued that policies such as healthcare access and raising the minimum wage reflect the core teachings of Jesus.
Advertisement
By yoking the church’s teachings with policies that change the material conditions of the disadvantaged, he has created new excitement for the left. He has also provided hope that the traditional distrust between progressives and religion might be thawing. Perhaps the two groups could find a common language, a path to power and a different way to govern after all?
More than that, Talarico tapped into a collective hunger for a different kind of politics, one with an older, more sturdy moral authority. As poet Philip Larkin observed in Church Going, “... someone will forever be surprising / A hunger in himself to be more serious.” The yearning for a politics of moral clarity cannot be separated from our times, which are complex, cynical and frightening, including global heating, AI, wars and growing wealth inequality.
In a time of disorder and leaders of dubious character, the re-establishment of a moral order offers something politics has struggled to provide for a long time. The New York Times podcaster Ezra Klein, who featured Talarico on his show in January, said what Talarico offers is something people seem to yearn for, “a language of morality, and even of faith, at a time of incredible cruelty”.
Would this approach work in Australia after such a long stretch of prosperity Christianity in the halls of power in Canberra? Currently on the Labor side, many of the party’s most powerful figures grew up in Catholic households and were educated in the Catholic system. The PM has previously cited, during his time as opposition leader, the parable of the Good Samaritan, stating that “our care for others should be neither conditional nor transactional”.
Advertisement
However, there are few overt displays of religiosity in Labor’s top ranks, though perhaps there does not need to be. Many of the Catholic church’s social teachings are baked into traditional Labor values such as care for the sick, represented by Medicare, rights for workers, and a social safety net. There is an argument that a traditional Labor agenda is by default an old-school leftist Catholic agenda due to the deep roots the church once had with the party. Jeff Kildea has written about those once strong links between Catholicism and Labor and how they have been severed in recent decades.
But such a debt to biblical ideals is whispered rather than shouted in Australia. The end of sectarianism, the decline of relevance of the church and an increase in multiculturalism has seen the landscape shift in Australia. Research by the United States Studies Centre noted that unlike the US, Australia is a largely secular nation where overt displays of religiosity in politics often make mainstream voters uncomfortable. In Morrison’s case, overt displays of his Pentecostalism were greeted with discomfort, with questions raised as to whether people consented to be blessed by him, while Rudd’s forays into more explicit faith were also noted.