Why spaghetti bolognese is rejected in Italy
Lifestyle Desk
In Bologna, the dish known as spaghetti bolognese does not actually exist. While it can be found on menus throughout Sydney and London, in school canteens across Britain, and inside jars on supermarket shelves globally, it is absent from the city that provided its name. Those who order it in a trattoria situated beneath the Two Towers will, at best, receive a pitying smile. More frequently, they will be served a plate of tagliatelle, accompanied by a brief lesson regarding local culinary history.
Advertisement
Few Italian dishes known internationally bear the name of a specific city. Arguments occasionally arise regarding the origins of carbonara, pizza or tiramisu. Yet, with spaghetti bolognese, the parentage is explicitly stated in the title, and it is the residents of Bologna themselves who insist on disowning it. Many locals consider the dish a heretical, misshapen outrage prepared only by individuals who lack knowledge of authentic Bolognese cuisine.
In February 2019, the then mayor, Virginio Merola, requested that his fellow citizens send him pictures of spaghetti bolognese seen abroad via Twitter, and he initiated the project by showing a chalkboard from a London eatery. He informed journalists that it was “embarrassing to be known around the world for something that doesn’t exist”.
This was not the initial attempt at a cleanup. A few months prior, the Accademia Italiana della Cucina had formally registered a recipe for spaghetti in a tinned tuna sauce with the chamber of commerce in Bologna, which was labelled “Bolognese style” and quickly praised by the press as the genuine spaghetti bolognese. In its eagerness to deny the existence of spaghetti with ragù, the Accademia had officially granted the city a dish now prepared throughout Italy, which appears to have originated near Rome during the early 1900s and possesses little or no connection to Bologna.
To grasp why spaghetti bolognese achieved such fame, one must look back. The primary reason is the name itself. The city’s reputation spread long before the pasta, which only emerged in the 1890s. Bologna had been a byword across Europe for centuries, owing to the cured meat that made it famous from the Renaissance onwards: mortadella.
Advertisement
In 1596, the pamphleteer Thomas Nashe mocked the poet Barnabe Barnes for strutting about court in “a codpisse as big as a Bolognian sawcedge”. His readers clearly understood the appearance of a Bologna sausage and required no further explanation. By 1660, Robert May’s The Accomplisht Cook was already providing a recipe for “Bolonia Sausages”, which English cookbooks continued to copy for generations. Mortadella was always produced for export, but from the late 19th century, once the city’s charcutiers had learned to tin it, the name of Bologna and mortadella knew no borders.
The second reason is that Bolognese ragù represented a small revolution. Neapolitan ragù, which is a century older, was made by braising a large joint of veal; its juices dressed the pasta while the meat was served as the main course. The Bolognese version incorporates minced meat directly into the pasta course, which becomes richer and does not rely on a costly, long braise. The logic is much the same as the hamburger, which swaps steak for mince to create something more practical and cheaper, yet every bit as good.
Ragù entered cookbooks in 1891, when Pellegrino Artusi published his “Maccheroni alla bolognese” in Science in the Kitchen and the Art of Eating Well, prepared with pancetta, lean veal, butter, onion, carrot and stock, and still no tomato. In this recipe, the true ancestor of ragù alla bolognese, the stars are dried durum wheat maccheroni, not yet tagliatelle. Spaghetti followed soon after. They first appeared in 1898, within an advertisement for the Hôtel Ville et Bologne in Turin offering “Spaghetti di Napoli alla bolognese”. Before ragù was ever paired with tagliatelle, it had already established a partnership with spaghetti.
In Bologna, it was fresh pasta that kept ragù company for the remainder of its history, but abroad, and especially in the United States, spaghetti bolognese took hold for an obvious reason. Egg pasta was difficult to find, so when Julia Lovejoy Cuniberti translated Artusi’s recipe in 1917, she was already suggesting the sauce for “macaroni or spaghetti”. In 1952, at a fair held at the Royal Festival Hall in London, even the Queen Mother recognised spaghetti bolognese with interest, just before being welcomed at the British stand with a cup of tea.
Advertisement
Tagliatelle and spaghetti went their separate ways while the recipe was still taking its first steps, but that does not mean spag bol has no right to exist. Perhaps one day the Bolognese will decide that having their city’s name known all over the world matters more than who gets to use it. Even then, tourists can rest assured that every time they order spaghetti bolognese, they will be corrected, kindly but firmly.