How we tested 369 gifts for our ultimate festive guide
Lifestyle Desk
The Filter HQ team has spent the year evaluating 369 presents for its 2026 Christmas gift guide, the publication says. The effort began after the staff stored away the previous year’s decorations and set out to create a comprehensive list of festive ideas.
Advertisement
A diverse group of testers, covering all ages and preferences, put each item through its paces. Fashion writer and stylist Sam Deaman, who handled men’s accessories and nightwear, recalled his partner’s irritation with nightly pyjama displays, saying: “It was like Stars in Their Eyes for Christmas gifts,” he says. “’Tonight, Matthew, I’m going to be … Ebenezer Scrooge!’”
Researcher Lily Smith organised a blind biscuit tasting in the Guardian kitchen. She reported that Fortnum & Mason’s spiced Christmas Merrilossus biscuits were the overall favourite, with Island Bakery’s lemon melts close behind – “we’ve included both in the guide as they have different flavour profiles,” she says.
Guardian columnist and chocolate specialist Annalisa Barbieri noted that many Christmas‑themed chocolate boxes prioritise appearance over taste, adding: “They are frequently style over substance – they look great but tend to taste crap,” she says.
Items that failed the trials included a “detox” bath salt that turned water brown, a camping lantern that died after a few hours, and a yoga kit with poorly designed balance blocks. Any gifts that could not be returned and had not been consumed were donated to charity.
Advertisement
For the teen and tween sections, writer Rhiannon Evans asked children what they loved most. She said many chose books and that Lego remained popular, observing: “So many chose books – there are some amazing YA series out there now,” she says. “I also underestimated how many kids, mainly tweens, still really like Lego. It was a bit of a reminder that while they’re probably begging for the latest £95 hoodie, that won’t be the present they end up truly loving.”
Runner and writer Laura Potter suggested outdoors‑oriented presents such as durable running socks and a water bottle that opens with one hand, advising: “The best thing to do if you’re buying for someone who loves to be outdoors is to look for a relevant treat: indulgent bath products for after a muddy hike, clothing or accessories that feel extra comfortable in all weathers, an ‘experience’ that fits with their activity of choice, or, if all else fails, a voucher for their favourite outdoorsy brand,” she says.
Guardian fashion editor Jess Cartner‑Morley criticised stocking fillers that start at £100, remarking: “Those lists where ‘stocking fillers’ start at £100 drive me bananas. Who are these people? One full stocking would bankrupt you.” She added that small, useful items can be more appreciated, noting that “Gifts can be all shapes and sizes. They don’t have to be showy,” and “A nice thing that will happily live in a drawer feels thoughtful: hence, socks.” Beauty columnist Sali Hughes contributed selections such as jumbo hair clips, an espresso martini cracker and Niwaki fridge‑magnet scissors.
Most of the guide’s recommendations are priced under £100, though a few big‑ticket items are also featured. The Filter encourages shoppers to explore its other guides for additional tested ideas, from gifts for parents to presents for teens and tweens.