Debate grows over use of AI in credit scoring
Business Desk
The experience of Hope highlights the importance of credit scores, yet such metrics often fail to capture the entire financial picture. Funmi Olufunwa, a consumer finance lawyer and founder of the financial education business Hoops Finance, noted that the nation is overly obsessed with credit scores. In the UK, Experian, Equifax and TransUnion generate these scores, typically relying on similar data sets.
Advertisement
Olufunwa explained that credit scores are backward looking as they focus on past events rather than predicting future behaviour. She stated that lenders are primarily concerned with affordability when deciding whether to provide money. Traditional systems frequently disadvantage thin-file applicants, including young people and those who have recently moved to the UK, because they lack an established credit history.
With vast amounts of financial data now accessible and a rising interest in using artificial intelligence to process it, some suggest AI could assist lenders in identifying reliable borrowers. In the US, lending decisions often rely on FICO scores, which utilise information from the three major credit assessment firms. However, AI-focused companies such as Upstart and Zest AI are providing lenders with alternative methods for assessing creditworthiness.
Upstart stated that their machine-learning models examine more than 2,500 variables, which they believe allows them to provide significantly more loans at low prices to borrowers across all demographic groups. Sarah Tucker, a mortgage expert and the CEO and founder of The Mortgage Mum, noted that AI has the potential to help lenders analyse much broader sets of information. She added that it can identify patterns more quickly and build a more individual picture of someone's affordability and risk. Tucker believes that if technology enables lenders to better understand thin-file applicants instead of applying rigid rules, there is a real opportunity to improve financial inclusion.
However, concerns remain regarding the use of AI in everyday decision-making. Tucker explained that consumers need to understand what information is being used to make decisions about them, and they must be able to challenge something when it is wrong. Sandra Wachter, a professor of Technology and Regulation at the University of Oxford, noted that credit scores have been a contentious topic for decades for this reason. She argued that we are not assessing if past decisions were right, and suggested that AI does not know about existing social inequalities that impact decisions and could just replicate what it has seen in the past.
Advertisement
While firms such as Upstart and Zest AI view technology as a tool for financial inclusion, Wachter believes that real transformation requires accountability alongside automation. She stressed that firms must apply existing regulations and establish new guardrails to ensure that AI does not simply perpetuate the biases of the past. She warned that not putting any safeguards in place will fortify, foster, and enhance discrimination.
Upstart stated that it is tackling that issue by investing in creating objective, automated evaluations to identify bias. The company added that they have incorporated those evaluations into their model training process so it evolves to become even more accurate and more fair over time.