Scottish government bonds versus UK gilts: current developments
Business Desk
Economists say that issuing Scottish bonds – dubbed “kilts” – would cost more than borrowing through the UK’s National Loans Fund. They estimate the interest rate on kilts would be 0.3 percentage points higher than on gilts and that each bond would carry an extra £2 million in administrative costs. The Scottish government has not published detailed costings, saying market sensitivities prevent disclosure, but maintains the issue would be value for money compared with the UK route.
Advertisement
Ministers argue the bond programme could showcase Scotland to investors and would be useful if independence were achieved. Dr Ben Cormier, senior lecturer at the University of Strathclyde’s department of government and public policy, told Holyrood’s finance committee that while the bonds might be marginally pricier, they would "bring flexibility to public finances and debt management". McMillan said he supported the plans in principle but warned that limiting bonds to five‑year terms could damage credibility with investors.
He added that "full information" must be available and that "You've got to have a clear, full and frank conversation with the public". Conservative MSP Liam Kerr warned the bonds could be more expensive than borrowing via the National Loans Fund and raised concerns over transparency.