International talks on autonomous weapons regulation collapse
Tech Desk
Efforts spanning an entire week to establish a negotiating mandate for a legally binding international treaty aimed at regulating autonomous weapons ended in failure just before 5am. The collapse occurred following all-night discussions that could not overcome objections raised by Russia.
Advertisement
Although an overwhelming majority of nations participating in the UN’s Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) in Geneva sought a mandate for a legally binding treaty, the requirement for consensus compelled the conference to settle for a significantly weaker alternative. This mandate requested that countries “to elaborate by consensus” an instrument that might lack legal obligations.
Russia spearheaded the objections through obstructive stalling techniques. However, other military powers invested in AI warfare, such as the US, were also hesitant to commit to a binding protocol designed to protect civilians from robot drones and autonomous weaponry.
Some participants contended that existing international humanitarian law was adequate. Over 100 states had advocated for new legislation, arguing that these weapons presented entirely new challenges, while European and Nato states, including Ukraine, China and Iran, indicated support or willingness for a new protocol.
The US stated that the necessity for human oversight of autonomous weapons had been addressed during the Apec summit in meetings between president Xi Jinping and Donald Trump this week, though the US remained reluctant to support a binding treaty. Furthermore, South Korea, Japan, Turkey, the UK, France and Germany, all of which are defence tech powers exploring AI-enabled weapons, also resisted being bound by new law, preferring a nonbinding agreement.
Advertisement
Operating through consensus, the CCW requires all 128 parties to the convention to agree unanimously to pass a statement. This high threshold has prevented the CCW from passing any new weapons regulations in the past 30 years, leading states to seek alternative pathways for treaties, such as the 2008 ban on cluster munitions.
Max Tegmark, chair of the Future of Life Institute, remarked that world leaders failed to meet the moment this week. “Slaughterbots are already here,” he said. “Yet states have agreed it is sufficient to just talk about this for the 14th year.”
Diplomats present at the negotiations suggested that Russia had been deliberately filibustering and failing to act in good faith, in contrast to US delegates who were attempting to find a path toward a consensus statement. The exclusion of various nonmember countries from the talks also sparked a rare protest in the chamber on the final day, with the Egyptian delegation shouting at the conference chair.
Israel and the US have utilised AI-enabled targeting systems to conduct tens of thousands of strikes in Gaza and Iran, resulting in mass casualties. The Pentagon struck more than 1,000 targets in Iran on the first day of the war, and according to investigative media reports, the US military is aiming to carry out 1,000 AI-assisted targeting decisions per hour.
Advertisement
Critics described the outcome as a missed opportunity, pointing out that states have been debating the dangers of autonomous weapons and the need for international regulations for 13 years, with large substantive parts of a treaty already settled. One European diplomat commented: “There was no political will to really regulate these weapons. No will commensurate to the urgency and need.”
Bonnie Docherty, a senior arms adviser at Human Rights Watch who was involved in previous treaties banning cluster munitions and nuclear weapons, stated that autonomous weapons require binding law. She noted that treaties could be negotiated within 15 months and dismissed the US proposal of five years to finalise a mandate.
A group of seven countries – Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama – had led the campaign for a binding treaty to be negotiated within one year. On Wednesday, the Brazilian delegate told the floor: “These are not weapons of the future being discussed here, these are already in use and being further developed. We are late in developing these norms and rules to regulate these lethal autonomous weapons systems.”