US lawmakers plan more tech regulations following 2026 legal battles
Tech Desk
With only a few weeks remaining in the year, legislators are attempting to pass new protections for victims of online harm prior to the close of 2026. These efforts specifically target creators of deepfakes and technology platforms that restrict users from filing lawsuits.
Advertisement
On Tuesday, a Senate Judiciary subcommittee held a hearing to advocate for the end of forced arbitration regarding online harms. The primary focus was Roblox, which was accused of avoiding legal complaints concerning children allegedly groomed on the platform. The company reportedly enforces its own forced arbitration clause against users who agreed to terms while minors, in some instances involving children under 10 years old. Nearby, Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) and Laurel Lee (R-FL) were joined by hotel heiress Paris Hilton at the Capitol to support the Defiance Act. This legislation would allow victims of nonconsensual intimate deepfakes to sue their creators.
“The best thing we can do in terms of enforcement is we can open up the courthouse doors,” Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO), who chairs the Judiciary subcommittee, stated to reporters following the Roblox hearing. “The more I see these companies evade regulations, the more I think there is nothing as powerful as a jury.” Hawley, alongside ranking member Dick Durbin (D-IL), introduced a bill to make arbitration agreements unenforceable for disputes involving alleged child sexual exploitation or “child cyber injury,” which encompasses “reputational harm, mental suffering,” or death.
Roblox has attempted to use its arbitration clause in lawsuits it faces over allegations that users were groomed on the platform as minors, despite the company asserting it provides protections. The company is currently facing roughly 180 lawsuits in a consolidated case regarding its alleged failure to protect children. Under the current arbitration process, the public would not see legal discovery similar to that revealed in recent cases against Meta. Hawley described the jury system as “corruption-proof” and “an incredibly big hammer.”
Roblox has denied accusations that it is attempting to dodge accountability. “Safety has been central to Roblox since we launched. We require age checks for chat, place users under 16 in age-based accounts with protective defaults, and block images and video in chat,” Nicky Jackson Colaço, Roblox’s global head of public policy, said in a statement. “A legal position about arbitration is not a measure of a company’s safety record, and a hearing built around it fails to advance safety.”
Advertisement
Congress has just over three weeks left in session before the year concludes, and a new Democratic majority will take office in January. Republicans are expected to prioritise the confirmation of President Donald Trump’s nominees for judgeships and executive posts, such as FCC commissioner, during the lame-duck session. They also intend to pass year-end legislation like the National Defense Authorization Act, which often includes various policy items. However, some lawmakers remain hopeful that they can enable new litigation regarding deepfake abuse and child predation.
Litigation has become one of the more effective methods for survivors of online harm to seek change. While Congress has struggled to pass prominent privacy, child safety, and consumer protection bills, it has begun addressing the deepfake issue via the Take It Down Act. Simultaneously, individual plaintiffs and attorneys general have secured significant legal wins and settlements despite the broad protections of Section 230. Should bills like the Defiance Act or those ending forced arbitration pass, tech firms and perpetrators of online harms could face a new wave of legal challenges.
In addition to the Hawley-Durbin bill, Sens. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), Katie Britt (R-AL), and Cory Booker (D-NJ) introduced similar legislation with a different approach that explicitly includes data privacy violations. During the Roblox hearing, Northwestern University law professor Myriam Gilles, an expert on forced arbitration, noted she has testified before Congress many times but “never expected to come before this body to talk about its use against 9 year olds.” She added that passing either proposal would have a profound impact, stating, “You will be amazed by how quickly the company will change its behavior once it is sued in public court.”
The Defiance Act aims to allow victims of nonconsensual intimate deepfakes to sue creators for damages, thereby increasing the cost of producing such images. Hilton visited Washington earlier this year to describe how an intimate non-deepfake video of her, shared without consent at age 19, affected her life. She used her personal experience to advocate for the Defiance Act. At Tuesday’s press conference, she confirmed she would return to Congress as often as required to see the bill become law. “Some people might have thought that was the end of my fight,” Hilton said. “But when I make a”