Corporate homicide probe urged over NHS Grampian patient deaths
Health Desk
A consultant surgeon has requested a corporate homicide inquiry following allegations that numerous patients at NHS Grampian died unnecessarily due to surgical complications. Dr Habib, who has been employed in General Surgery and HPB since 2014, claims that hundreds of patients have experienced harm due to an exceptionally high rate of complications.
Advertisement
Dr Habib stated that he identified avoidable surgery-related fatalities as early as 2016. He formally escalated his concerns regarding dozens of potential avoidable deaths in July 2021 and subsequently discussed the matter with Police Scotland in February 2024.
According to the consultant, an unpublished 2022 external expert report examined 45 cases and determined that 19 of those deaths, or 42%, were avoidable. Dr Habib asserted that NHS Grampian showed "wicked recklessness and an indifference to patient deaths" and argued that a corporate homicide investigation is necessary.
The surgeon noted that he has contacted the Scottish health secretary and the first minister multiple times since June 2023, though the government maintained it lacked the jurisdiction to review his whistleblowing claims. Additionally, he stated that the Independent Whistleblowing Officer declined to advance his complaints.
In December 2025, Dr Habib contacted Laura Skaife Knight, the chief executive of NHS Grampian, regarding the issues. Ms Skaife Knight responded: "I would be grateful if you can let HIS (Healthcare Improvement Scotland) complete its enquiries rather than continuing to correspond with me about these matters, as I have nothing further to add to this response at this stage."
Advertisement
Reflecting on the institutional response, Dr Habib remarked: "They are avoiding accountability by not being transparent about what damage has been done, while promising heaven and earth going forward."